What’s different about Google Home?
Much of the underlying technology is similar to the Amazon Echo with AI, natural language processing and voice recognition powering both devices. Google are promoting it as a portal to their search and online services, with access tied into your Google account.
However, Google Home is said to offer greater flexibly in terms of voice commands, accept looser commands and respond to questions contextually. Amazon Alexa uses utterances to invoke its Skills, and these have to be phrased in a precise way, eg Open Spotify playlists.
What can it do?
Organise your calendar, set reminders, run home automation, play music and access a range of web services.
How much will it cost?
The initial pricing is a reasonable £129 for early adopters. Although this may be rapidly reduced as the entry level Amazon Echo Dot device currently retails for around £50 making it more appealing to price conscious consumers.
What challenges does Google Home face?
Points of difference
Both devices offer fairly similar functionality so without a killer app it could be difficult for Google to differentiate the device in the marketplace.
Both devices rely on personal data being captured and stored in the cloud, with recent surveillance cases and privacy breaches making us slightly more wary about what we share, and what information is being recorded.
Amazon have created alliances with many home automation and media companies, and it’s as yet unclear as to whether they can offer comparative services.
Amazon have won over large sections of the developer community by offering excellent tools, documentation and support for Alexa Skills and using familiar frameworks such as Node.js and Amazon Web Services. Google typically offer comprehensive tools and powerful APIs so they need to court developers, and incentivise producing content and services for Home.
Who will win the battle of the living room?
This is too early to call, and it’s likely that both devices will coexist in an emerging sector. Amazon have the advantage of being earlier to market with strong initial sales (around 11 million devices worldwide), excellent brand recognition and a healthy developer community with around 10,000 Alexa Skills available.
Google may have some catching up to do, not least in terms of consumer confidence dented by recent reports about extremist content on YouTube. Having said this it would be foolish to write off such a potentially interesting addition to the market, with customers seeing clear benefits of this competition.